Traducción/Translation

Translating Humor –Not Fun at All

Leer en español

Have you ever watched a movie in a language other than English? You may be familiar, in a broad sense, with the culture where it was originally made, so you enjoyed it.

However, it may happen at times that you just do not understand why these people find some things so funny. “What are they laughing about?” “What do people see in this movie?” Why does this happen?

Humor has always been a great challenge for translators. Translators do not just transfer words from one language into another. They also transfer cultural aspects from the source language culture. And one of the biggest cultural expressions is found in humor —in the form of jokes, comic-books, or even sitcoms and movies.

Their creators resort to a number of resources to generate a certain effect. But most times these have no equivalent in the target language, and when the text arrives at the hands of the translator, he or she is faced, once more, with every translator’s nightmare: untranslatability. But the desire to transfer this cultural expression, making it available to the target audience for them to enjoy as well, drives the translator to try to find a way to tackle challenges.

There are two factors, among others, which are used in humor and can represent a huge drawback for translators —language resources and cultural aspects.

Language Resources

Every language has a wealth of linguistic resources which can be used by comedians. English, for instance, allows for a lot of puns —there are words with several meanings, homophones, etc.

“I can handle this. ‘Handle’ is my middle name. Actually, “handle” is the middle of my first name.” (Chandler Bing, Friends, S. 3 E. 17.)

Spanish also has a lot of resources to create a humorous effect. The comedy-musical group Les Luthiers makes full use of the resources provided by Spanish language and Latin American culture.

Con mis fuerzas casi extintas,
a vasto imperio llegué.
Puse pie en tierra de incas,
o sea, hice hincapié.

(Cantata del adelantado Don Rodrigo Díaz De Carreras)

Acudid en mi ayuda, decidme qué debo hacer en este momento aciago… así hago algo. (El rey enamorado)

Quien conociera a María, amaría a María

You can find additional examples, both in English and in Spanish, in the footnote 1[1].

Cultural Issues

Many times, comedians make use of specific situations known by people living in a certain place at a certain time. There is a shared knowledge which allows them to understand the joke.

Puente polaco

Acentos norteños

Untranslatable?

Jokes cannot be explained. Then, what can a translator do when facing some of these issues? Depending on each case, it is possible to use a correspondence, or perhaps the translator will have to change the joke in full. Some translators omit the jokes, or translate them literally, and hence the humorous effect is absolutely lost. This is what happens with Chandler Bing’s comment in Friends. Subtitles read:

─Permítanme. “Soportar” es mi nombre. En realidad es solo una parte de mi nombre.

The translation is literal and not funny at all, because it is impossible to change the character’s name to create a pun.

Translators need to remember two key points:

  • Different cultures laugh at different things. Even if someone understands the joke, they may not find it funny. You would not make a joke about Polish people if you are in Warsaw, would you?
  • You need to evoke the same effect. This is not a word meaning translation, but a transfer that intends to achieve a specific effect for the target audience.

What do you think? Your opinions and suggestions are welcome! Did you enjoy the article? Like it and share it with your friends!

Click here to find out how I can help you meet your linguistic needs.

Sources:

https://www.rd.com/jokes/

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0108778/characters/nm0001612?ref_=tt_cl_t5

http://transcripts.foreverdreaming.org/viewtopic.php?f=177&t=11586

http://www.livesinabox.com/friends/scripts.shtml

https://the-big-bang-theory.com/?act=quotes&action=livesearch

https://www.musica.com/letras.asp?letras=18211

https://www1.icsi.berkeley.edu/~chema/luthiers/086.html

https://www1.icsi.berkeley.edu/~chema/luthiers/106.html

http://www.cmtv.com.ar/discos_letras/letra.php?bnid=171&tmid=56442&tema=SERENATA_TIMIDA

http://www.lesluthiers.es/op046.htm

[1] Here are some examples, although there are a lot more, and even better:

Ted: Robin, it’s fine. You said you wanted a dog and you got one. And the best part is: he got his shots.

Nate: Hey, guys, got my shots.

(How I Met Your Mother, S. 6 E. 18.)

Raj: I don’t like bugs, okay. They freak me out.
Sheldon: Interesting. You’re afraid of insects and women. Ladybugs must render you catatonic.

(The Big Bang Theory, S. 3 E. 2.)

Chandler: Well, this one’s for you.

Joey: Get out!

Chandler: I can’t.

(Friends, S. 2 E. 14.)

Chandler: It’s time to settle down. Make a choice. Pick a lane.

Joey: Who’s Elaine?

(Friends, S. 4 E. 7.)

Cultivarán las flores
de todos los colores
la lívida lavanda, la caléndula
y el lívido alhelí
la lila color de lila, y la rara lila blanca
y la lila color de lila, y la rara lila blanca
la rara lila, la rara lila
la lila lila y la rara lila
la lila lívida, la lila lívida
y la rara lila.

(Aria agraria, “tarareo conceptual”, Les Luthiers)

Poeta: ¿Cuánto valen su humildad y su decoro?

Eco: Oro, oro.

Poeta: ¿Quién es hermosa cual estrella?

Eco: Ella, ella.

(El poeta y el eco, Les Luthiers)

No escapa a cualquier espectador sagaz, y cuando decimos “espectador sagaz”, no confundir “espectador” con “encendedor”, aunque este último a veces también es “a gas”. Decíamos, si el espectador… sí, son esas cosas uno no… Si el espectador es sagaz, no debe escapársele (bueno también si el encendedor es a gas no debe escapársele), no debe escapársele el hecho de que… (Serenata tímida, Les Luthiers)

Los palacios que nos arrebatan
eran tan grandes, tan imponentes,
que no nos alcanzaban los sirvientes.
Y hoy si nos alcanzan, nos matan.

(El zar y un puñado de aristócratas, Les Luthiers)

─Was ist das?

─¿Qué es esto?

─Nein! Nein!

─Nueve, nueve.

(Muerte y despedida del dios Brotan, Les Luthiers)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s